Medical Aid consumers benefit by joining young
Author: BHF Published: 11/29/2018
Medical Aid consumers can avoid “late joiner penalties”, imposed on applicants joining
medical schemes later in life, by joining a scheme early in their careers when they are
younger and healthier.
Late joiner penalties are additional fines added to contributions of member applicants who
are 35 years and older when they first apply for membership or as beneficiaries to a medical
scheme. Schemes use these to minimise risk since the Medical Schemes Act (MSA) bars
them from declining membership applications.
Late joiner penalties once implemented are applicable for life, and these are a fixed
percentage of medical scheme contributions. It should be noted that medical scheme cover
can be costly and late joiner penalties make it more difficult for beneficiaries to afford cover
later in life.
According to Charlton Murove, Board of Healthcare Funders of Southern Africa’s Head of
Research, there are gaps in the MSA which provides medical schemes sector regulatory
framework. This Medical Schemes Act is built on three core principles.
“First, there is no price regulation, yet schemes are required to pay for Prescribed Minimum
Benefits in full. This means medical schemes have to pay for these benefits in full despite
what the provider charges. In some instances, schemes pay millions to treat a single
member in a year.
“Secondly, schemes are supposed to charge the same contributions for all beneficiaries
despite difference in age and health status of the beneficiaries. This is the principle of
community rating,” Murove said. Schemes may only differentiate the contributions by income
and family size of the principal member.
Lastly, there is the principle of open enrolment that says schemes must provide coverage to
everyone who wants to join yet there is no compulsory membership,” said Murove.
This leaves schemes prone to anti-selection, where new beneficiaries tend to have a worse
risk profile than the beneficiaries’ schemes are covering. Late joiner penalties are a provision
in the MSA that may be used by schemes to protect themselves from anti-selection.
Medshield Principal Officer Thoneshan Naidoo said the protection from risk offered by the
penalties was not adequate.
“They do not provide adequate funding to make up for those members who join late and
then claim for high cost biologic medicines that are priced in excess of R1 million for
“For example, a member who has not been contributing to a medical scheme for 25 years
will have a 75% penalty. It would take a further 23 years of this member’s contributions to
fund a R1 million treatment,” said Naidoo.
Late joiner penalties are paid indefinitely. Schemes are obliged to report a member’s late
joiner status when they terminate membership so that new schemes can continue imposing
the additional costs.
These additional costs are supposed to encourage people to join when they are much
younger and healthier. Hosmed Executive Principal Officer Dr Vusi Memela said this is the
best way to avoid permanent penalties.
“Ideally members should be joining a scheme earlier when they’re young and healthy and
may make use of the screening and preventative care benefits timeously, thus reducing the
burden of disease and high cost events later,” Dr Memela said.
Various other people also risk qualifying for late joiner status and having penalties perhaps
unfairly added to their contributions. This includes people unemployed for longer than three
consecutive months and unable to pay contributions while still hunting for another job.
“The high unemployment rates prevalent in South Africa especially in the young ages
compound the problems of low scheme membership in the young ages,” Murove explained.
Additional costs to subscriptions also render many health citizens unable to afford
Dr Memela said: “Affordability is a general concern in recent economic times for all and not
only newly joining members. The recent publication of the Council of Medical Schemes'
Annual Report 2016/17 indicates a decline in new members joining medical schemes.”
Another group who could find themselves vulnerable are people who are out of the country
for longer than the stipulated period. Upon their return to South Africa they may be charged
The only people exempt from these penalties are those who can prove that they were
adequately covered by a previous scheme. This is referred to as “creditable coverage”.
Some schemes, like GEMS, opt for waiting periods rather than impose late joiner penalties.
This is another form of restriction MSA allows.
For more information and interviews contact:
frayintermedia: Account manager
Tel: +27 11 888 0140
Cell: +27 79 847 8975
Board of healthcare funders of Southern Africa: Head: Stakeholder Relations
Tel: +27 11 537 0236
Cell: +27 82 903 1856